“But if our unrighteousness demonstrates the righteousness of God, what shall we say? Is God unjust who inflicts wrath? (I speak as a man.) Certainly not! For then how will God judge the world?” (Romans 3:5-6).
The Apostle Paul’s response to the convoluted reasoning of Romans 3:5 was to say once again, “That’s unthinkable!” (GW). If God were to dismiss human sin, then how could He hold the members of His human creation accountable for their behavior? As one paraphrase renders this passage, “…If God were not entirely fair, how would He be qualified to judge the world? (NLT).
To understand why the premise of Romans 3:5 unravels, it helps to remember that God is both holy and just. The word “holy” means “set apart” and conveys the idea of absolute moral purity. “Holiness” means that God is completely separate from anything that may be wrong, dirty, or impure. It also expresses the qualities of honor, virtue, and ethical perfection by extension.
When we describe God as just, we are referring to the fact that He acts with complete fairness and equity in every aspect of His dealings with humanity. The Old Testament concept of a “just” individual communicates the idea of someone who is lawful, righteous, and/or correct. The New Testament concept of this word identifies someone who is virtuous, innocent, faultless, and/or guiltless.
These concepts are frequently associated with the word “righteous” in both testaments. This simply refers to one who does what is right, and helps explain Paul’s sharply negative reaction to the suggestion that God might condone human sinfulness simply because it displays His righteousness to a greater degree.
We can also turn to a helpful analogy with respect to the scenario Paul offers here in Romans 3:5-8. For example, how many of us would keep a broken clock on a wall of our home simply because it happens to display the correct time twice a day? In that instance, most of us would repair the clock or discard it in favor of a replacement. In a similar manner, God does not accept human sinfulness simply because it serves to accentuate His purity on occasion.
While our sin may highlight God’s righteousness, that is not a valid excuse for God to reward it. As mentioned earlier, Paul likely fielded such questions from those who sought to discredit him and ease their discomfort over the implications of the gospel message. If that was the case, then the following verses will demonstrate that Paul was more than prepared to meet that challenge.
Image Attribution: Original photograph: Audrius Meskauskas; derivative work: Jahoe., CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons